Film Rhythm After Sound: Technology, Music and Performance

His Girl Friday (Howard Hawks, 1940)

Film Rhythm After Sound (University of California Press, 2015) analyzes the rhythmic dimensions of performance and sound in a diverse set of case studies: the Eisenstein-Prokofiev collaboration Ivan the Terrible, Walt Disney’s Silly Symphonies and early Mickey Mouse cartoons, musicals by Ernst Lubitsch and Rouben Mamoulian, and the impeccably timed dialogue in Howard Hawks’s films. In the early years of the transition to sound, filmmakers experimented with different strategies for synchronizing speech, sound effects and action. Music often served as a blueprint for rhythm and pacing, as was the case in mickey-mousing, the close integration of music and movement in animation. However, by the mid-1930s, filmmakers had also gained enough control over dialogue recording and editing to utilize dialogue to pace scenes independently of the music track.

Table of Contents

Bibliography

Image shows a cartoon pig dressed in overalls sitting at a piano with a brick wall background and a music sheet on the right side with musical notation.

From Clip 7 of Film Rhythm After Sound


“I’ll start with a simple declarative statement: this is a brilliant book. If you care about the way that movies are made and experienced, you need to read it. Now.”

— Kent Jones, Film Comment

CLIPS CITED IN
FILM RHYTHM AFTER SOUND

Clip 1. Song o’ My Heart, sync-sound scene compared to music-and-effects version

Clip 2. Pett and Pott, commuters scene

Clip 3. Ivan the Terrible, Part I, Ivan speaks to the boyars, introduction

Clip 4. Ivan the Terrible, Part I, Ivan rises

Clip 5. Three Little Pigs, shot 15

Clip 6. Three Little Pigs, first agitato

Clip 7. Three Little Pigs, wolf’s final assault

Clip 8. Playful Pluto, wind vortex

Clip 9. Playful Pluto, water hose

Clip 10. Love Me Tonight, noise prelude

Clip 11. Love Me Tonight, arrivals at the chateau.

Clip 12. Monte Carlo, first conversation

Clip 13. Monte Carlo, second conversation

Clip 14. Trouble in Paradise, conversation

RELATED ARTICLES

ON THE TRANSITION TO SOUND

Diagram of a molecular physics experiment showing atomic collisions with four numbered atoms and a trapezoidal area labeled with two molecules, A and B, with electron orbitals illustrated.

“Dialogue Scenes in the Period of Multiple-Camera Shooting: The Example of Arrowsmith

Lea Jacobs | in Aesthetics of Early Sound Film: Media Change around 1930 | ed. Daniel Wiegand | Amsterdam University Press, 2023

Black and white photo of two men in conversation. One man is sitting on a chair with legs crossed, wearing a suit and show, and is listening with headphones. The other man is lying on a table or bed with his legs propped up, dressed in a suit, and gesturing with his hand.

“The Innovation of Re-recording in the Hollywood Studios.”

Lea Jacobs | Film History, vol. 24, no. 1 (2012)

Black and white photograph of a theater stage with a performer and a group of people, including an orchestra, crew, and audience members, preparing for a performance.

Love Me Tonight [1932] and Rhythm in Early Sound Film with Lea Jacobs.”

Listen | Devan Scott, podcast | December 26, 2023


ON ANALYZING EDITING AND SOUND

“Digital Tools for Film Analysis”

Lea Jacobs and Kaitlin Fyfe | in The Arclight Guidebook to Media History and the Digital Humanities | ed. Charles R. Acland and Eric Hoyt | Reframe Books, 2016.

“Keeping Up with Hawks”

Lea Jacobs | Style, vol. 32, no. 3 (Fall 1998).

Black and white photograph of a film or television studio set, resembling a 1930s office, with people dressed in period clothing. A woman in a striped suit and hat is waving to the camera, surrounded by various crew members and actors, with filming equipment and lighting visible.

Howard Hawks seated on dolly on the newsroom set of His Girl Friday


ON EISENSTEIN’S USE OF MUSIC

“Rethinking the Sync: Adorno, Eisler and Eisenstein”

Lea Jacobs | new online publication | Download PDF

Two monks standing on a rocky mountaintop, dressed in dark robes, with one holding a staff against a cloudy sky.

Dawn-before battle sequence from Alexander Nevsky with original audio | Download clip

A detailed music notation chart with sections labeled from Shot I to Shot XII showing sheet music, diagrams of pictorial composition, movement diagrams, and picture frames at the top, documenting a visual and musical sequence.

Eisenstein’s chart with additional notations | Download chart

Boris Volsky’s “Memories of Prokofiev”

Translated by Ben Brewster | Download PDF